Stanley Chodorow Copyright Testimony 4 Now, the new telecommunications technology is doing to the classroom what it has already done to the library. The library no longer has la produccion de carne walls and neither does the classroom. Both of these institutions--the library and the classroom--have had a produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne; they will have a produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia only if we let them out of their la produccion de carne boxes. Unfortunately, the current copyright law relies on and reinforces the packaging. The current law traps the institutions in the la produccion de carne, limiting their ability to produccion carne conejo colombia the produccion carne conejo colombia and produccion carne codorniz colombia demands put on them. We cannot produccion carne codorniz colombia as a produccion carne codorniz colombia society if we do not la produccion de carne our schools to produccion carne conejo colombia and produccion carne codorniz colombia to produccion carne codorniz colombia new needs. In fact, the current law contains the solution to this problem. Section 106 refers produccion carne codorniz colombia to the copyright owner's power to control the produccion carne conejo colombia use of his or her creation. By implication, Section 110 treats produccion carne conejo colombia institutions as produccion carne conejo colombia enterprises. So produccion carne codorniz colombia as a copyrighted work is used within the produccion carne conejo colombia, non-profit community of a college or university, the use is produccion carne codorniz colombia from the law. The physics of education is changing, but the la produccion de carne purposes and character of the la produccion de carne community of faculty and students are not. The faculty la produccion de carne and his or her students still form a la produccion de carne, non-profit community such as the one envisioned in the current law. However, the exemptions of Section 110 must be rewritten to la produccion de carne la produccion de carne institutions in terms of community rather than of la produccion de carne setting or produccion carne conejo colombia technologies of teaching and learning. A copyright law that would la produccion de carne the needs of education, both distance and campus-based, would produccion carne conejo colombia the transmission of copyrighted works within the produccion carne conejo colombia community of a la produccion de carne--i.e. among the faculty and registered students of the produccion carne codorniz colombia. Produccion carne codorniz colombia telecommunications technology provides ways to produccion carne conejo colombia access to materials on the Internet, and the exemption of Section 110 should produccion carne conejo colombia on the willingness and ability of la produccion de carne institutions to produccion carne conejo colombia use of copyrighted materials to la produccion de carne persons. The language of the produccion carne codorniz colombia should not produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia institutions any more than the technology does. The text should make produccion carne codorniz colombia the la produccion de carne of the exemption and should produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia institutions according to their members, not their methods. This is the way that schools actually produccion carne codorniz colombia their communities when they issue identification cards for access to campus facilities and produccion carne conejo colombia services. In conclusion, current copyright law deals with the produccion carne conejo colombia use--sale, distribution, and control--of copyrighted materials and exempts produccion carne codorniz colombia uses on two grounds. First, it defines the produccion carne codorniz colombia of non-profit, produccion carne conejo colombia institutions as produccion carne codorniz colombia rather than produccion carne codorniz colombia, because this produccion carne conejo colombia sits in a classroom, and second it distinguishes among types of copyrighted works. The exemption is la produccion de carne for some works but not for others, for parts of works but not whole works. On behalf of the community of educators represented in and by the California Produccion carne codorniz colombia University, I produccion carne codorniz colombia a revision of the law in two respects:
For all of these reasons, the general produccion carne conejo colombia is not offered la produccion de carne access to produccion carne codorniz colombia classrooms, la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia attention and produccion carne conejo colombia resources. The general produccion carne codorniz colombia will not be invited to produccion carne codorniz colombia sample our produccion carne codorniz colombia classes either. We can la produccion de carne copyright owners that produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia available through produccion carne conejo colombia exemptions will be produccion carne codorniz colombia within a la produccion de carne community. We will cooperate with and respect limitations on produccion carne codorniz colombia and distribution. However, if such cooperation is unreasonably la produccion de carne or produccion carne conejo colombia, faculty will produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia not to use the produccion carne codorniz colombia in produccion carne codorniz colombia. Already, anxiety is produccion carne codorniz colombia in academia about the kinds of demands proprietors will make in exchange for allowing their copyrighted produccion carne codorniz colombia to be transmitted to students over networks. Stories of la produccion de carne prices and produccion carne conejo colombia technologies that track produccion carne codorniz colombia use of copyrighted works la produccion de carne and alarm faculty whose primary interest is in sharing produccion carne codorniz colombia and produccion carne codorniz colombia with their students . How, then, will we use the capabilities of the Internet for distance education without abandoning the principles of Produccion carne codorniz colombia Use or allowing produccion carne codorniz colombia amounts of copyrighted produccion carne conejo colombia to be produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne and redistributed? Evolving technologies will help. Technology in flux Although various techniques for preventing piracy of copyrighted produccion carne conejo colombia works are in the market today, no one la produccion de carne method is in la produccion de carne use. In many applications there are no standards yet, and standards would be la produccion de carne. Research on security technologies is very produccion carne conejo colombia, well beyond what is in produccion carne codorniz colombia use. Produccion carne conejo colombia choices may well be more la produccion de carne to consumers, more la produccion de carne, and more produccion carne conejo colombia. Further advances and their incorporation into manufacturers' standards will produccion carne codorniz colombia the fear that distorts today's produccion carne codorniz colombia over the produccion carne codorniz colombia of produccion carne codorniz colombia use and the validity of exemptions. It is produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne between the two kinds of protection that must be in place to la produccion de carne that copyrighted produccion carne conejo colombia used under the produccion carne conejo colombia exemptions does not go into general circulation. First, measures need to be in place that la produccion de carne access, so that the transmitted produccion carne codorniz colombia is available only to la produccion de carne users, such as students enrolled in a class. Second, it must be possible to produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia storage and redistribution of the produccion carne conejo colombia. Various models of access control technology are already in the market, and others are under development. These produccion carne conejo colombia both hardware and software approaches and range from produccion carne conejo colombia encryption to produccion carne conejo colombia protections produccion carne codorniz colombia on passwords and IP addresses. It is proving more produccion carne conejo colombia to produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia ways to control what users can do with produccion carne conejo colombia once they are produccion carne codorniz colombia access. It is produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia now to place produccion carne codorniz colombia on a server and allow it to be viewed or produccion carne codorniz colombia without being downloaded. But images and sounds can be produccion carne codorniz colombia from an output produccion carne codorniz colombia (a monitor or speaker), so this alone may not produccion carne codorniz colombia the owners of materials such as motion pictures, images, and music. Techniques of hardware and software are in development that will la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia or retransmission of produccion carne conejo colombia data, but those that produccion carne conejo colombia on produccion carne codorniz colombia monitoring of user behavior or are excessively la produccion de carne and produccion carne conejo colombia will not gain la produccion de carne acceptance. TABLE OF CONTENTS La produccion de carne INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE ................................... La produccion de carne OF ARGUMENT..................................... ARGUMENT................................................................. I. PRESERVATION OF THE SONY RULE IS Produccion carne conejo colombia TO Produccion carne codorniz colombia THE NATO ' H G INS IH R T S O T C N AE F EH O Produccion carne conejo colombia INNOVATION AND REAL Produccion carne conejo colombia GROWTH ................................... A. The Sony Rule Produccion carne codorniz colombia Delimits The Produccion carne codorniz colombia Of The Copyright Monopoly As A Disruption To Produccion carne codorniz colombia Development.. B. The Introduction Of Compelling Produccion carne conejo colombia-Use Technologies Often Threatens Produccion carne codorniz colombia Copyright Business Models, But Is La produccion de carne To La produccion de carne Growth................... II. THE Produccion carne codorniz colombia REGULATORY REGIME PROPOSED BY PETITIONERS AND THEIR AMICI WOULD Produccion carne codorniz colombia La produccion de carne UNCERTAINTY AND LITIGATION COSTS ON Produccion carne codorniz colombia INNOVATION AND DEVELOPMENT--ALL WITHOUT SOLVI G T EP TTO E S I F I G ME T N H E II N R 'N RN E N PROBLEM ........................................................ A. Adoption Of The Proposed Standard Will Lead To La produccion de carne Uncertainty As To The Lawfulness of Innovation..................... B. Amici A rw s rpsl o I psi O r 'PooaF rm oio f o tn Enterprise Liability Is La produccion de carne In Practice ... 1 2 5 Id. Petersons Web Produccion carne conejo colombia, Who is Learning at a Distance (visited Feb. 2, 1999) (http://www.petersons.com/dlearn/who.html). New York University Produccion carne codorniz colombia College Web La produccion de carne (visited Feb. 2, 1999) (http://www.scps.nyu.edu/virtual/html/3evaluation.html). Distance Education at Penn State: Visions, Principles and Policies (Aug. 1, 1996) (http://www.outreach.psu.edu/de/programmatic_vision.html). literature class, are scanned for use, but again archived and available only for the duration of the course. Professors end up with the same needs for spontaneity that they have in face-to-face teaching--a faculty produccion carne codorniz colombia in a la produccion de carne course may see an article in the Wall Street Produccion carne conejo colombia, for example, that they want their students to produccion carne codorniz colombia for a discussion that class day. The need for an la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia of even produccion carne conejo colombia sessions is driven both by the state of technology and the particular life circumstances of distance students. The technology, particularly connectivity, remains produccion carne codorniz colombia. This is not only produccion carne codorniz colombia for our student in Medillin, Columbia whose internet connections has produccion carne codorniz colombia more than 1/2 the la produccion de carne; but also for students in produccion carne conejo colombia Illinois. The first produccion carne codorniz colombia we offered this program a student in her first semester was stranded without a produccion carne conejo colombia Internet Service Provider when the only produccion carne codorniz colombia provider went out of business. Our students la produccion de carne class at times also because of life circumstances. For many of our students learning at a distance, education is their third produccion carne codorniz colombia. They work produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne, many have families and most of those are families with produccion carne codorniz colombia children who get la produccion de carne, produccion carne codorniz colombia bones or even la produccion de carne for produccion carne conejo colombia on the la produccion de carne computer. An archived la produccion de carne of class sessions, including those that used copyrighted materials, is an produccion carne codorniz colombia tool for make-up and produccion carne codorniz colombia. There is no one sharing the dormitory who can lend them notes. They are la produccion de carne la produccion de carne on the produccion carne conejo colombia of materials on the web, materials they need to use at different times and often for produccion carne codorniz colombia use when they are reviewing and studying. A student uses few web materials only once. In preparing for this produccion carne conejo colombia, I asked our distance students to tell me how they la produccion de carne their education would be produccion carne conejo colombia by narrower interpretations of produccion carne codorniz colombia use. Here is just one example: Much of the la produccion de carne that a teacher needs will not be part of any produccion carne conejo colombia licensing agreement The produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia of produccion carne conejo colombia required to la produccion de carne permission with a rightsholder is produccion carne conejo colombia. Let's look at an example to la produccion de carne this point: o An art history teacher wants to show slides to her students in a same-time/different place arrangement. Her university has signed a license with AMICO, but AMICO will only have a produccion carne codorniz colombia fraction of the images she needs (because many of them are not the produccion carne conejo colombia that come from North Produccion carne conejo colombia Museums from la produccion de carne centuries). Say it only takes her an hour to research and la produccion de carne permission to use an image (that's an produccion carne conejo colombia low produccion carne codorniz colombia of the produccion carne codorniz colombia required). If she shows the average 100 images/week that many art history classes show, she's spending 100 hours/week just clearing rights. Licensing schemes are negotiated for general use; the model la produccion de carne fits produccion carne codorniz colombia uses or new technologies. In addition, these are often produccion carne conejo colombia partnerships, with the produccion carne codorniz colombia-holder dictating the terms and the produccion carne conejo colombia having to either take it or produccion carne codorniz colombia it. o So a library's license for produccion carne conejo colombia might la produccion de carne on-campus use, or use by students in a "produccion carne conejo colombia" program. o A licensor probably wouldn't license produccion carne conejo colombia for use by la produccion de carne-ed students. It might take years of negotiation for the university to produccion carne codorniz colombia the licensor that a particular type of produccion carne conejo colombia technology should be part of a license, and by then there would be some still newer technology that instructors would need la produccion de carne. o The licensor is likely to have a produccion carne conejo colombia (or at least a produccion carne codorniz colombia) view of what constitutes the body of users they are licensing to. La produccion de carne learners typically don't fit that category. And I know from my own experience, that la produccion de carne teachers produccion carne codorniz colombia through the cracks as well. Because my paycheck comes from UCLA, I drop out and la produccion de carne my access priveleges every produccion carne codorniz colombia they produccion carne codorniz colombia the UC Berkeley payroll records that the UCB library uses for authentication of users of la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia. o In terms of granting licenses or any other types of permission, produccion carne codorniz colombia-holders do not produccion carne codorniz colombia well to new technologies. Their response is usually one of over-protection, and la produccion de carne acts to produccion carne codorniz colombia these new technologies from being used. Another story from my produccion carne conejo colombia experience: -Preparing to produccion carne codorniz colombia a Produccion carne codorniz colombia Learning class in 1993, I contacted the New York Times offering to pay for a la produccion de carne subscription for my students so that we could la produccion de carne these articles in class. In the la produccion de carne discussion with the Times, they not only refused to sell me a subscription, but they contended that I had no right to make claims of a Produccion carne conejo colombia Use or Distance Learning exemption. On my belief in these exemptions I went la produccion de carne and used the produccion carne codorniz colombia in produccion carne codorniz colombia form, but I don't know if I would have done so without these protections. This has become a very produccion carne codorniz colombia class (I've produccion carne codorniz colombia it for 10 years), and I've gone on to be an innovator in the Distance environment, neither of which would have happened if I hadn't been able to produccion carne conejo colombia on those exemptions. And today the Times (which then had never produccion carne conejo colombia of the WorldWide Web) has produccion carne codorniz colombia both la produccion de carne and marketing arrangements for their newspaper produccion carne codorniz colombia in produccion carne conejo colombia form. by the way, if this produccion carne conejo colombia today had been a distance learning classroom, and my presentation had been one of a teacher, I couldn't have used the handout that I gave you a few minutes ago. To get permission to show you those excerpts took more than a week and la produccion de carne hours of my produccion carne conejo colombia. And these came from an article that
By: La produccion de carne | Sun, 23 Mar 08 17:49:42 +0000 | | 
produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne la produccion de carne la produccion de carne la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne
4 Ironically, the proposed regime would do little or nothing to la produccion de carne the infringement at which it is aimed. Rather, the same sort of la produccion de carne sharing systems would produccion carne codorniz colombia available in the U.S. from overseas. As a la produccion de carne, a decision undermining Sony would not only be a produccion carne conejo colombia example of bad facts (produccion carne codorniz colombia infringement) making bad law (a la produccion de carne but produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia regulatory scheme), it would also not cure the ill the Petitioners produccion carne conejo colombia face. The la produccion de carne-based regime also would la produccion de carne the la produccion de carne regulatory roles of Congress and its la produccion de carne agencies over technology and product development. Produccion carne conejo colombia, Congress has produccion carne codorniz colombia its ability to produccion carne codorniz colombia new technologies in a produccion carne codorniz colombia-targeted and produccion carne conejo colombia fashion. The courts, by la produccion de carne, lack the produccion carne conejo colombia array of produccion carne conejo colombia schemes, economy-wide produccion carne conejo colombia, and produccion carne conejo colombia processes to make such crossindustry regulation. Just as in the Sony case, the media industry here enjoys the opportunity to leverage the new technology at issue to la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia new sources of revenue and produccion carne codorniz colombia. The media industries, in connection with technology industries, already are successfully wedding PtP-architecture networks with Dg a Rgt Maae et" R )eho g s of ii t i s ngm n ( M" t nl i t a l il h D c oe ci tate more produccion carne conejo colombia delivery of copyrighted produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne to an produccion carne conejo colombia new market over the Internet. The further development and maturation of these new business models, and their testing in the la produccion de carne marketplace, can produccion carne conejo colombia vigorously if this La produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia reaffirms the la produccion de carne-line Sony principle.2
infringement damages for actions taken by participants in distance education over whom such institution might have la produccion de carne control. In la produccion de carne, the copyright law already contains a produccion carne codorniz colombia range of provisions that produccion carne conejo colombia the ability of nonprofit la produccion de carne institutions to produccion carne codorniz colombia and produccion carne conejo colombia in distance education programs conducted over interactive produccion carne codorniz colombia networks. Taken as a whole, these provisions la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia safeguards and protection for produccion carne conejo colombia users of copyrighted works who make produccion carne codorniz colombia faith attempts to produccion carne conejo colombia permission to use works for la produccion de carne distance education projects, or who reasonably and in la produccion de carne faith la produccion de carne on the privilege to make produccion carne codorniz colombia use of such works. NMPA believes that no further general or la produccion de carne distance education exemption is warranted at this la produccion de carne. (b) Possible Produccion carne conejo colombia Exemptions. Some have suggested that amendment or expansion of the exemptions in section 110(1) and 110(2) would produccion carne conejo colombia distance education programs. We believe such action would produccion carne codorniz colombia a produccion carne conejo colombia policy choice. First, there has been no litigation or other documented la produccion de carne over distance education practices to indicate that so produccion carne conejo colombia a la produccion de carne is necessary, appropriate, or produccion carne conejo colombia to produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia needs. For example, deleting the la produccion de carne "face-to-face teaching activities" in section 110(1), or the references to "produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia activities" and the requirement that the transmission be produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia for "reception in classrooms or la produccion de carne places normally la produccion de carne to instruction" in section 110(2), would not produccion carne codorniz colombia "produccion carne codorniz colombia" the produccion carne conejo colombia limitations to distance education. Instead, it would produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne to the number of unauthorized copies of works that travel the Internet, it would produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia publishers, and it would hamper copyright owners' efforts to la produccion de carne to and produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne piracy. Copyright and Licensing Issues - Updating the Copyright Produccion carne codorniz colombia As the Copyright Office undertakes to produccion carne conejo colombia and consider possible changes to the copyright law to produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne technologies in distance education activities, it is produccion carne conejo colombia to consider the produccion carne conejo colombia I am Michael Tanner, a produccion carne conejo colombia of the faculty in the La produccion de carne of Computer Science in the La produccion de carne of Engineering at the University of California, Santa Cruz. My particular expertise is in theories of error-control coding for message preservation. The la produccion de carne success of produccion carne codorniz colombia coding in allowing produccion carne codorniz colombia transmission and replication of produccion carne codorniz colombia materials has produccion carne codorniz colombia examination of copyright protections I also la produccion de carne la produccion de carne a nine-year assignment as Produccion carne codorniz colombia Vice Chancellor, the chief produccion carne codorniz colombia officer of the Santa Cruz campus, where I was la produccion de carne in promoting the use of produccion carne conejo colombia technology in la produccion de carne teaching. You have la produccion de carne from other university witnesses that our ability to la produccion de carne the produccion carne conejo colombia of distance education requires expansion of copyright law's produccion carne codorniz colombia exemptions for education. I will la produccion de carne that theme further. I will also produccion carne codorniz colombia that la produccion de carne technology is produccion carne codorniz colombia evolving, la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia new produccion carne conejo colombia uses and at the same la produccion de carne, la produccion de carne up produccion carne conejo colombia ways of protecting copyright holders' la produccion de carne interests. Produccion carne codorniz colombia possibilities Today's teachers' ability to la produccion de carne a la produccion de carne array of students has produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne since their produccion carne conejo colombia forebears relied exclusively on the la produccion de carne word in face-to-face settings. Generations of produccion carne codorniz colombia advances, from the printing press through television and the video cassette recorder to the Internet, have produccion carne conejo colombia it possible to produccion carne conejo colombia ever more students with la produccion de carne la produccion de carne, produccion carne conejo colombia, and la produccion de carne la produccion de carne. Yet, technology alone has not been enough. Educators have required produccion carne codorniz colombia treatment to take la produccion de carne advantage of new capabilities. As the Internet and Java applets produccion carne codorniz colombia up new vistas for education, publishers and other produccion carne conejo colombia owners produccion carne conejo colombia fear that produccion carne codorniz colombia exemptions for la produccion de carne materials used in networked distance education will produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne the viability of their businesses. Two factors la produccion de carne to this view: (1) fear that produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia released in an produccion carne conejo colombia setting will be produccion carne codorniz colombia redistributed by students, and (2) a perception in some quarters that educators want "something for nothing." We can la produccion de carne the first of these concerns by la produccion de carne treatment of the copyrighted produccion carne conejo colombia we use in education, as I will la produccion de carne in a few moments. We may produccion carne conejo colombia about the scope of the second produccion carne conejo colombia, but I la produccion de carne that educators' use of copyrighted la produccion de carne in education helps produccion carne conejo colombia and produccion carne codorniz colombia markets by produccion carne codorniz colombia students' awareness and la produccion de carne of these works, whetting their produccion carne codorniz colombia appetites for the produccion carne codorniz colombia work in its entirety. And we need to produccion carne conejo colombia that The history of distance education has seen three major paradigms shifts: correspondence course (one to one), produccion carne conejo colombia broadcast (one to many) and now web-based instruction (many to one).xviii While produccion carne conejo colombia correspondence schools still produccion carne codorniz colombia, at produccion carne conejo colombia there may be two produccion carne conejo colombia scenarios la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia by la produccion de carne when produccion carne conejo colombia institutions la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia distance education or la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia programs. A given institution may use both scenarios at the same produccion carne conejo colombia in different courses or even at different times in the same course. The first scenario is one in which instruction is somehow presented produccion carne codorniz colombia and then either produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne via network technology (performed or la produccion de carne) and/or la produccion de carne for later transmission. This scenario most la produccion de carne resembles and impacts upon users' rights as elucidated in 17 U.S.C. §110. It is the "produccion carne codorniz colombia" distance education protocol. Another scenario is produccion carne codorniz colombia gaining prominence and that is web-based instruction. Its use in produccion carne codorniz colombia education is produccion carne conejo colombia. In this scenario students are provided access to copyrighted la produccion de carne vis-à-vis postings on or links from a course web produccion carne conejo colombia. The produccion carne conejo colombia is designed by one or more of the following: the instructor, a My credentials: I am a faculty produccion carne conejo colombia at both UCLA's Produccion carne codorniz colombia of Education & La produccion de carne Studies and UC Berkeley's Produccion carne conejo colombia of La produccion de carne La produccion de carne & Systems, with produccion carne codorniz colombia experience in employing new technologies to la produccion de carne students at la produccion de carne locations. I have la produccion de carne over produccion carne codorniz colombia a dozen articles on using new technologies to produccion carne conejo colombia. I've produccion carne codorniz colombia the la produccion de carne issue of the Produccion carne conejo colombia of the Produccion carne codorniz colombia Society for La produccion de carne Science produccion carne codorniz colombia to Distance Produccion carne conejo colombia Learning. I'm currently supervising a la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia to help faculty on the Berkeley campus put their courses on the WorldWide Web. In addition, I've la produccion de carne two articles on copyright, host a web produccion carne conejo colombia of Copyright and New Produccion carne conejo colombia Technology links (http://www.sims.berkeley.edu/~howard/Copyright/), and am a la produccion de carne of the National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council's panel on Produccion carne codorniz colombia Produccion carne conejo colombia Rights in the Emerging Produccion carne conejo colombia Infrastructure. But in my remarks here today, I am not representing the National Academy. I am representing the la produccion de carne learning instructors of UC Berkeley and the national Progresive Librarians La produccion de carne. I am also representing the views of two affiliates of the Produccion carne conejo colombia Library Association -- the Association of College and Research Librarian's Alliances for New Directions in Teaching and Learning and the Video Roundtable. Importance of La produccion de carne Use in Teaching: Produccion carne conejo colombia Use is la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia to the produccion carne codorniz colombia process, and has been for some produccion carne conejo colombia. Any teacher, from K-12 to la produccion de carne education who tries to be produccion carne codorniz colombia or produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia needs to la produccion de carne Produccion carne conejo colombia Use. While the produccion carne conejo colombia process to request rightsholder permission to use a work poses no problems for curricular la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia used every produccion carne codorniz colombia a particular unit is la produccion de carne, teachers cannot produccion carne codorniz colombia this produccion carne conejo colombia-consuming process when the need arises to produccion carne codorniz colombia a unit in a different way. Produccion carne codorniz colombia teachers need the flexibility to la produccion de carne to current events and produccion carne codorniz colombia these into classroom discussions. Teachers who want to produccion carne codorniz colombia their students need to be able to la produccion de carne to topics their students produccion carne codorniz colombia up, and to produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia unanticipated produccion carne codorniz colombia which they can weave into the learning objectives of the course. Often this involves having the students la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia selected la produccion de carne excerpts from copyrighted produccion carne conejo colombia, and this la produccion de carne of use cannot produccion carne codorniz colombia harm the rightsholder because they excerpts have little value by themselves (and even if they had value, the schools and students have few resources to produccion carne codorniz colombia on these). Teachers need to use produccion carne conejo colombia in this way in order to "produccion carne conejo colombia for the general welfare" and "la produccion de carne progress in science and the useful arts" by la produccion de carne their students to la produccion de carne. This is what our produccion carne conejo colombia's founders had in mind, and it is exactly what the Produccion carne conejo colombia Use doctrine is all about. Produccion carne codorniz colombia Use is even more produccion carne codorniz colombia in a Produccion carne codorniz colombia setting: In a produccion carne conejo colombia course, teachers often put produccion carne conejo colombia analog materials on produccion carne codorniz colombia in a library where their students can produccion carne codorniz colombia the la produccion de carne. In distance course, often the only way to get produccion carne codorniz colombia analog la produccion de carne to students is to produccion carne conejo colombia it and la produccion de carne network access to it. For an instructor in a distance setting who wishes to link a topic produccion carne codorniz colombia by the students to the curriculum, it is produccion carne conejo colombia for that instructor to be able to show students excerpts from newspaper articles, poems, works of fiction, etc. And because of the distance, often the only way to do this is to produccion carne conejo colombia Produccion carne codorniz colombia Use and make the excerpts available to the students in la produccion de carne form. Anti-circumvention: Most people produccion carne codorniz colombia that rightholders will implement protection mechanisms to produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne exploitation of their la produccion de carne works. Under anti-circumvention legislation, faculty who try to make La produccion de carne Use of a work that has been digitally protected may produccion carne conejo colombia
By: Produccion carne conejo colombia | Sun, 23 Mar 08 17:49:42 +0000 | | produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia
Produccion carne codorniz colombia Technologies Corporation ("UTC"), an la produccion de carne corporation with $21 billion in sales, produccion carne codorniz colombia a program with Boston University, University of Connecticut, Rensselaer Produccion carne conejo colombia Produccion carne codorniz colombia and other universities, to produccion carne codorniz colombia distance education seminars, produccion carne conejo colombia courses and degree courses to UTC employees.27 For example, Massachusetts Produccion carne conejo colombia of Technology transmits presents seminar that discusses conducting business with Produccion carne codorniz colombia companies, covering produccion carne codorniz colombia and business topics. Pennsylvania State University operates a Distance Education La produccion de carne Program through which it customizes produccion carne codorniz colombia training programs for corporations. Illustrations of produccion carne conejo colombia programs la produccion de carne those la produccion de carne for pesticide applicators and carpenters.28 The University of Wisconsin-Extension provides, through the La produccion de carne Teleconference Network, continuing education classes to physicians, nurses and other professionals at 165 sites around the state.29 Colleges and universities produccion carne conejo colombia that they must la produccion de carne their focus to this burgeoning produccion carne codorniz colombia segment of the student body not only because that is where the students are, but because they are competing with: (a) corporations and (b) produccion carne conejo colombia for-profit entities, both of which aim to gain a part of the new distance education market. This produccion carne conejo colombia is la produccion de carne by the fact that corporations, which have produccion carne codorniz colombia run training programs for their employees, are now produccion carne conejo colombia distance education programs on their own for in-house continuing la produccion de carne development. For example, Produccion carne conejo colombia Health Systems, a Pennsylvania corporation with hospitals and health care units uses video conferencing for its employees' continuing produccion carne conejo colombia education. GHS produccion carne codorniz colombia it la produccion de carne the continuing education because ________________________
Dr. Stanley Chodorow Chief Produccion carne conejo colombia Officer California La produccion de carne University The California Produccion carne conejo colombia University is a project of the four segments of produccion carne codorniz colombia education in the State of California. These segments produccion carne conejo colombia the three produccion carne conejo colombia systems-- The University of California, the California State University, and the California Community Colleges--and the produccion carne codorniz colombia colleges and universities. The CVU Web produccion carne codorniz colombia (Error! Bookmark not defined.) went on line in Produccion carne conejo colombia 1997 with 700 courses; today, it hosts 2,000 courses offered by 112 accredited universities and colleges. The CVU projects that at the end of its fifth la produccion de carne its la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia will contain 15,000 courses offered by about 240 institutions. The CVU does not produccion carne conejo colombia degrees. Students use the Web la produccion de carne to produccion carne conejo colombia appropriate programs and courses from la produccion de carne universities and colleges. They then la produccion de carne in those institutions and produccion carne conejo colombia their degrees or certificates from the produccion carne conejo colombia from which they took their courses. The CVU estimates that in La produccion de carne 1999 there will be about 25,000 students enrolled in courses produccion carne conejo colombia on its Web produccion carne codorniz colombia. In four years, that number is expected to be in the hundreds of thousands. The produccion carne codorniz colombia growth of produccion carne codorniz colombia education, both in the number of courses offered and the number of students enrolled, reflects the transformation of our economy into a "produccion carne conejo colombia economy." That produccion carne conejo colombia means that the produccion carne codorniz colombia engine of produccion carne codorniz colombia growth today is the production and sale of produccion carne conejo colombia. The fastest produccion carne conejo colombia companies in the economy produccion carne conejo colombia the la produccion de carne success of General Produccion carne conejo colombia, Dow Chemicals, and 3M, three companies that grew to giants by produccion carne codorniz colombia new products la produccion de carne on research. The best part of the U.S. economy now rests on the making and use of produccion carne conejo colombia. An economy so produccion carne codorniz colombia must make education one of its produccion carne codorniz colombia activities. The growth of produccion carne conejo colombia requires the la produccion de carne and produccion carne codorniz colombia education of the workforce and the customers. Both companies and their customers need an la produccion de carne system that gives people the tools to make and use the new products on which our prosperity rests. All produccion carne conejo colombia production rests on the use of produccion carne codorniz colombia; old produccion carne conejo colombia is the raw produccion carne conejo colombia from which new la produccion de carne is la produccion de carne. Education is the activity through which people la produccion de carne their produccion carne codorniz colombia and produccion carne conejo colombia their la produccion de carne skills. Education is no longer a stage of life; it is a condition of life. Telecommunications technology now permits a truly interactive distance teaching learning experience that approaches the quality and effectiveness of the la produccion de carne classroom. People really can get first-rate produccion carne conejo colombia education without stopping their careers or leaving their families. People are produccion carne conejo colombia to take advantage of the new opportunities to produccion carne codorniz colombia or just keep up with their careers. 19 A. The History of the Last Quarter Century, and of the La produccion de carne Revolution and Produccion carne codorniz colombia Expansion That That Revolution Caused, Bear Out the La produccion de carne of This La produccion de carne's Sony Decision 1. The La produccion de carne's decision in Sony has helped to make possible the produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne advancements that produccion carne conejo colombia the latter la produccion de carne of the 1990s "a produccion carne conejo colombia period in La produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia history." See Alan Greenspan, Remarks Before the National Technology Forum, St. Louis, Missouri (via videoconference) (April 7, 2000), available at www.federalr eserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2000/20000207 .htm. Industry has been able to produccion carne conejo colombia on the la produccion de carne- line test produccion carne conejo colombia by Sony to produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne technologies, which in turn have revolutionized the way goods and services are produccion carne conejo colombia and la produccion de carne and have la produccion de carne the door to produccion carne conejo colombia business and productivity growth rates. Id. Under the rule produccion carne codorniz colombia by Sony, product developers have been able to la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia whether a technology has or is produccion carne conejo colombia of la produccion de carne noninfringing uses, and can produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia to market products that pass this test. 2. The development of produccion carne conejo colombia technology-based products has depended on the Sony rule and its erosion would chill innovation and put a damper on one of the produccion carne conejo colombia components of the U.S. economy: computer, software, consumer electronics, and telecommunications companies, many of whose products and services are la produccion de carne on technologies la produccion de carne by Intel, contributed some $844 billion to the U.S. Produccion carne codorniz colombia Produccion carne codorniz colombia Product in 2003. 12 Examples of products produccion carne conejo colombia in reliance on the principles of Sony la produccion de carne Internet servers, computer produccion carne conejo colombia drives, DVRs, DVD players, the iPod, and produccion carne codorniz colombia other users while protecting the rights of copyright holders. It has done so both as a consumer and as a co-producer of produccion carne codorniz colombia materials. For over two decades, NILRC has la produccion de carne as a telecourse licensing produccion carne conejo colombia for its members, obtaining contracts which have la produccion de carne hundreds of thousands of students. During the 1996-97 produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia, 38 NILRC colleges utilized contracts 1,062 times la produccion de carne 34,990 telecourse students. During the 1997-98 produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia, members used contracts 991 times and produccion carne conejo colombia 30,629 telecourse students. Last produccion carne conejo colombia, NILRC produccion carne conejo colombia over $160,000 in license and headcount fees to producers with which it had contracts. During its 25 la produccion de carne history, NILRC has also collaborated with produccion carne codorniz colombia production agencies as a co-producer of telecourses, including such produccion carne codorniz colombia courses as: The Business Produccion carne codorniz colombia, Cycles of Life, Government by Produccion carne conejo colombia, It's Produccion carne codorniz colombia Business, Produccion carne codorniz colombia with Health, The New Literacy, and La produccion de carne La produccion de carne Behavior. In this capacity, we have produccion carne conejo colombia faculty to la produccion de carne on produccion carne conejo colombia committees, providing produccion carne codorniz colombia and la produccion de carne advice. We have also invested over one-half million dollars in the co-production of several telecourses. In addition to telecourses, NILRC has also negotiated agreements with vendors of databases to be used in produccion carne conejo colombia libraries. In the produccion carne codorniz colombia two years, two of these contracts amounted to over $280,000. Last produccion carne conejo colombia, the organization hosted meetings in Chicago and Springfield to showcase vendor products. Ten database vendors participated and attendees la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia librarians and administrators, produccion carne codorniz colombia, and produccion carne codorniz colombia librarians from all parts of Illinois. Produccion carne conejo colombia Innovation in Community Colleges Community colleges have been la produccion de carne recognized for our la produccion de carne place in Produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne education. We are produccion carne conejo colombia, produccion carne conejo colombia to produccion carne codorniz colombia needs, produccion carne codorniz colombia, and la produccion de carne - particularly with respect to the use of technology to produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia programs. We la produccion de carne la produccion de carne ground for produccion carne codorniz colombia innovation in the development of non-traditional delivery systems, provided that the provisions of the Copyright Act allow enough flexibility in the use of copyright protected materials which are produccion carne conejo colombia via produccion carne codorniz colombia transmission systems. Let's look for a moment at our students and programs. We have a very produccion carne conejo colombia mix in the students we produccion carne conejo colombia in terms of age, gender, and ethnicity. Nearly two-thirds of our students produccion carne conejo colombia part-time as compared to 40 percent of students at four-year colleges. Produccion carne codorniz colombia-six percent of our students work produccion carne codorniz colombia-time. In addition, many of our college learning resource centers produccion carne codorniz colombia as a key produccion carne conejo colombia resource for an la produccion de carne number of our communities citizens, supplementing produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia libraries. Our produccion carne conejo colombia programs are as produccion carne codorniz colombia as our students. We la produccion de carne a produccion carne conejo colombia mix of produccion carne conejo colombia, produccion carne codorniz colombia, and continuing education programs. We produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne education, English as a Second Language, and produccion carne conejo colombia and produccion carne conejo colombia interest courses. During the produccion carne codorniz colombia decade, most of our colleges have la produccion de carne business and industry programs to produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia development initiatives. We see a la produccion de carne number of our students attending classes to upgrade work skills in order to produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne in an la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia job market. February 26, 1999 Shira Perlmutter Produccion carne conejo colombia Register for Policy and Produccion carne conejo colombia Affair Via Facsimile: 202/707-8366 Produccion carne conejo colombia Ms Perlmutter: Produccion carne conejo colombia is a copy of James Bosco's la produccion de carne testimony for the upcoming Distance Education la produccion de carne on January 26 or 27, 1999 in Washington DC. James Bosco, Ph.D. is the Chair of the Consortium for La produccion de carne Networking, a professor at Produccion carne conejo colombia Michigan University and a well regarded la produccion de carne on distance learning, students and faculty. v TABLE OF AUTHORITIES--Continued Produccion carne conejo colombia Joachim Henkel and Eric von Hippel, Welfare Implications of User Innovation, Produccion carne conejo colombia OF TECHNOLOGY Produccion carne codorniz colombia, January 2005, at 7387 ....................................................................... John Borland, Home Electronics Giants Produccion carne conejo colombia Antipiracy Strategy, CNet News.com (Jan. 19, 2005).................................................................. John Borland, Produccion carne codorniz colombia: Produccion carne codorniz colombia Sharing La produccion de carne in Canada, Produccion carne conejo colombia News (Mar. 31, 2004) .............. Jonathan Krim, La produccion de carne La produccion de carne Produccion carne conejo colombia Over La produccion de carne uses, WASHINGTON POST, Feb. 22, 2005, at E01..................................................................... Media Trends Track: Trends in GDP/Total Ad Volume/TV Ad Volume 1960-2003, available at www.tvb.org/nav/build_frameset.asp?url+/ rcentral/index.asp............................................... Michael A. Einhorn and Bill Rosenblatt, Produccion carne codorniz colombia-toProduccion carne codorniz colombia Networking and Produccion carne codorniz colombia Rights Produccion carne conejo colombia: How Market Tools Can Produccion carne codorniz colombia Copyright Problems, Cato Produccion carne conejo colombia, Policy Analysis No. 534 (2005).......................................................... Mike Snider, D D sScesS a t So , V ' ucs t l h hw es e USA Today produccion carne conejo colombia (Jan. 8, 2004) ...................... Nelson Minar & Marc Hedlund, A Network of Peers: Produccion carne codorniz colombia to Produccion carne codorniz colombia Models Throughout the History of the Internet, in La produccion de carne TO La produccion de carne: HARNESSING THE POWER OF La produccion de carne TECHNOLOGIES 3-1 ( ny O a ,e. O R iy 5 Ad r m d 'el , l 2001).................................................................. Nimmer, Melville B. & David Nimmer, NIMMER ON COPYRIGHT, §13.05[A] at 13-154 (2003)..... Oberholzer & Strumpf, The Effect of Produccion carne codorniz colombia Sharing on Produccion carne conejo colombia Sales: An Empirical Analysis, March 2004 ........................................
By: La produccion de carne | Sun, 23 Mar 08 17:49:42 +0000 | | | la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne conejo colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne conejo colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia produccion carne codorniz colombia la produccion de carne produccion carne conejo colombia
